Monica Murphy’s “Playing Hard to Get” is the first book in The Players series, an engaging tale of college romance set against the backdrop of college football. The story unfolds on a college campus where our protagonist, Knox Maguire, is the football team’s star offensive tight end and the king of the campus.
His life takes an unexpected turn when he crosses paths with a shy, quiet girl who is his polar opposite in every aspect. This novel is more than a simple love story; it’s a narrative about self-discovery, trust, and the courage to step out of one’s comfort zone.

Title | Playing Hard to Get |
Author | Monica Murphy |
Genre | Fiction, Romance |
Language | English |
Publication Date | December 1, 2022 |
Length | 396 pages |
Where to Purchase
The Intriguing Plot
The plot catches your attention right from the start, with the contrasting personalities of Knox and the unnamed female protagonist creating a tension that keeps the pages turning. She’s quiet, shy, and fresh out of a breakup, whereas Knox is loud, popular, and the ultimate player known across the campus.
When she becomes his English tutor, she’s determined to keep their interaction strictly professional, a resolution that is tested as they spend more time together. The dynamics between them change gradually, bringing them closer in a way neither of them anticipated.
The story takes a delightful turn as they find themselves getting hot and heavy in the library, a place once symbolic of their contrasting lives. Their growing attraction is palpable, and as they get to know each other better, they realize there’s more to their relationship than just physical attraction.
The budding romance between Knox and the female protagonist is tender, filled with the anxiety and excitement that come with new love, and readers will find themselves rooting for them despite the odds.
Character Analysis
Knox Maguire is portrayed as a typical college athlete – confident, popular, and not shy about his conquests. However, beneath the facade, there’s a person with fears and insecurities, making him a relatable character.
On the other hand, the female protagonist, whose name we later find out to be Joanna, is introverted, intelligent, and cautious, especially around Knox whom she deems as a player. The author does a wonderful job of portraying her internal struggle as she battles her growing feelings for Knox against her fear of getting played.
Monica Murphy has crafted well-rounded characters whose interactions feel genuine. The dialogues are witty, the banter between Knox and Joanna is entertaining, and the chemistry between them is electrifying. As Knox pursues Joanna earnestly, their romance blossoms, revealing a tender, emotional connection that goes beyond the physical attraction.
Final Thoughts
“Playing Hard to Get” is a captivating read that explores the uncertainties of young love, the thrill of the chase, and the vulnerability that comes with letting someone into your heart. The narrative is engaging with a good blend of humor, emotional depth, and romantic tension that will keep readers invested in Knox and Joanna’s story.
The college setting, the football backdrop, and the opposites-attract trope are well-utilized to create a believable and enjoyable narrative. Whether you’re a fan of sports romances or new adult romances, this book is a delightful addition to your reading list.